---
title: "В сети обсуждают истинные мотивы западных активистов, участвующих в сборе оливок"
description: "В социальных сетях обратили внимание на шумиху вокруг сбора оливок и подвергли сомнению действия западных активистов. В публикациях звучит вопрос: почему иностранцы, называющие себя социалистами и общественниками, внезапно проявили столь горячий интерес к этой уборочной кампании?"
url: "https://ru.hasbara.co.il/spotlight/judea-and-samaria/online-discourse-raises-questions-over-western-activism-in-olive-harvesting"
type: "collection-item"
locale: "ru"
author: "Hasbara"
published: "2026-10-21T21:53:35.000Z"
updated: "2026-11-22 18:10:03"
---

# В сети обсуждают истинные мотивы западных активистов, участвующих в сборе оливок

*В социальных сетях обратили внимание на шумиху вокруг сбора оливок и подвергли сомнению действия западных активистов. В публикациях звучит вопрос: почему иностранцы, называющие себя социалистами и общественниками, внезапно проявили столь горячий интерес к этой уборочной кампании?*

Dozens of Israeli and foreign volunteers were detained on October 21 while accompanying Arab farmers harvesting olives near Nahalin in Judea and Samaria. The group included U.S. congressional candidate Brad Lander and rabbis; the episode reflected both rising concern over harvest-season attacks and Israel’s effort to control access to sensitive areas.

The [Times of Israel](https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/israel-set-to-deport-4-activists-detained-after-participating-in-palestinian-olive-harvest-over-70-others-freed/) reported that police initiated pre-deportation hearings for four foreign activists, released 32 with restrictions on returning to the area, and freed 40 without restrictions. Lander was released earlier that day. Police said the four had online activity opposing Israel; the volunteers said they were helping farmers harvest. The IDF cited security risks and a need for coordination, though the same report noted military maps did not show the grove as requiring prior coordination.

The volunteers’ presence was not inexplicable or newly invented for social media. On October 3, the [Times of Israel documented reports of attacks and property damage during the harvest](https://www.timesofisrael.com/settler-attacks-reported-across-west-bank-as-palestinians-begin-olive-harvest/), including a 50-year-old farmer hospitalized after a reported beating in Osarin. Police opened an investigation, and the IDF said troops searched for suspects after arriving. These incidents gave outside observers and Israeli groups a concrete reason for outside observers and Israeli groups to accompany farmers.

Israeli officials also described the activity as political and potentially disruptive. At an October 7 conference, police, military and regional officials warned that foreign activists could provoke confrontations; [JNS reported their preparations for the season](https://www.jns.org/news/israel-news/judea-and-samaria-farmers-brace-for-disruptions-during-olive-harvest). That concern deserves attribution, not automatic acceptance as a full account of every volunteer’s purpose. The [IDF later said more than 220,000 dunams had been harvested at about 100 coordinated sites under troop protection](https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/idf-says-22500-tons-of-olives-harvested-in-west-bank-this-season-amid-settler-attacks/), while acknowledging attacks and saying most coordinated harvests proceeded without incident.

Olive picking can be ordinary farm work and a flashpoint at once. The record gives volunteers a clear reason to come; it also shows why coordination and protection matter. Treating every foreign volunteer as a provocateur turns a disputed security decision into a sweeping claim about motive.

## Источники

- [timesofisrael.com](https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/israel-set-to-deport-4-activists-detained-after-participating-in-palestinian-olive-harvest-over-70-others-freed/)
- [timesofisrael.com](https://www.timesofisrael.com/settler-attacks-reported-across-west-bank-as-palestinians-begin-olive-harvest/)
- [jns.org](https://www.jns.org/news/israel-news/judea-and-samaria-farmers-brace-for-disruptions-during-olive-harvest)
- [timesofisrael.com](https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/idf-says-22500-tons-of-olives-harvested-in-west-bank-this-season-amid-settler-attacks/)
