Медиа18 ноября 2026 г.

The video was first published in May 2021 and shows an earlier Egyptian convoy.

David Rosenfeld

David Rosenfeld — псевдоним редакции «Факты и мифы» Hasbara. Статьи этой редакции пишутся и публикуются автоматически искусственным интеллектом, и перед публикацией их никто не проверяет.

Миф

A video shows Israel blocking an Egyptian humanitarian aid convoy bound for Gaza at the border in October 2023.

Факт

The video was first published in May 2021 and shows an earlier Egyptian convoy. It does not document an Israeli refusal at the border in October 2023.

A video circulated online in October 2023 does not show Israel stopping an Egyptian aid convoy at the Gaza border. The footage was published more than two years earlier, in May 2021, and depicts a different convoy. Its recycled date and setting turn a real aid-delivery video into false evidence about a separate crisis.

The post’s accusation appeared during a genuine dispute over access for aid trucks waiting in Egypt. That timing made the old footage seem plausible, but the visual record identifies another event. AFP Fact Check traced the video to Egyptian broadcaster Al Nahar TV, which posted the same footage on its official Facebook account on May 31, 2021. The broadcaster’s Arabic caption described Egypt sending another convoy of support and aid to Gaza. The video carried the channel’s watermark, and matching frames appeared in a report published by Israeli outlet N12 on June 28, 2021.

The footage belongs to an earlier delivery

The date matters because the central accusation is about a specific convoy allegedly turned away in October 2023. AFP found the original clip from 2021, while N12’s June 2021 report described regular truck traffic from Egypt through the Salah al-Din crossing. It said more than 100 trucks entered Gaza through that crossing each day at the time. N12 reported that Israeli security officials wanted Egypt to supervise goods moving through the route, but its account describes a functioning crossing and trucks entering, not the convoy shown in the viral post being refused entry.

The old clip therefore cannot prove that Israel blocked the convoy in October 2023. Its original publication predates the Hamas-led October 7 attack and the ensuing emergency by over two years. A video recorded and shared in 2021 cannot show Israeli decisions made in response to events in October 2023, even if the later caption places it at the same border.

This correction is specific to the footage and the claim attached to it. It does not mean that aid movement in October 2023 was immediate or uncomplicated. Trucks carrying relief supplies did wait in Egypt, and the crossing became a subject of negotiations and security arrangements. Those facts need evidence from October 2023, rather than an older video.

October’s aid deliveries were a separate event

On October 21, 2023, the first group of 20 aid trucks entered Gaza through the Rafah crossing from Egypt. The next day, according to Egypt’s Al-Ahram Online, a second convoy of 17 trucks began crossing and reached Gaza later that night. The report said Israel had approved the entry of food, water and medical supplies after a request from U.S. President Joe Biden; Israeli security officials inspected the cargo before its entry.

Those reports describe delays and controls, not the scene in the recycled clip. Al-Ahram reported that the second convoy was delayed and that Israeli bombing near the crossing had interrupted preparations on Gaza’s side. It also reported that the first 20 trucks had crossed on Saturday. The distinction is important: a real delay in October does not authenticate unrelated footage or establish what happened to the trucks appearing in a different video.

Nor does the clip establish a pattern of systematic refusals. It shows a convoy from 2021, before the event it was used to illustrate. The original post by Al Nahar TV presented the footage as Egypt’s aid effort, and contemporary N12 reporting documented large volumes of Egyptian trucks entering by a separate crossing. For October 2023, the documented timeline instead includes trucks waiting, negotiations over entry, and convoys crossing Rafah on October 21 and 22.

Viral captions often merge actual developments with images from another time. In this case, the October aid crisis was real, but the video offered as proof of an Israeli refusal was not from that crisis. Matching the footage to its 2021 publication and comparing it with contemporaneous reporting separates the two events: the clip records Egypt’s earlier aid convoy, while October’s deliveries followed a distinct process at Rafah.

Источники

  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
    Gaza gets second humanitarian aid convoy from Rafah crossing after delay but no fuelhttps://english.ahram.org.eg/NewsContent/1/1234/510778/Egypt/Foreign-Affairs/Gaza-gets-second-humanitarian-aid-convoy-from-Rafa.aspxНедостоверный

Доступность

Настройки сохраняются на этом устройстве.

Предпросмотр

Читайте так, как вам удобно

Настройте страницу во время чтения. Открыть материалы

Текст
Размер текстаПрименяется ко всему сайту.
Цвет и контрастность
Тема
Движение
АнимацияНастройка устройства учитывает уменьшение движения.